top of page

Tax for musicians in the UK and four issues worth checking

Nov 4
5 min read
Musicians Tax Advisor UK

A European engagement has gone well, but the promoter will not release your fee until an A1 certificate arrives. A royalty payment gives you a particularly good year, but your accounting method prevents you from claiming a relief that could help.


These are the points where tax becomes very real for musicians. It affects when you get paid, how much you keep and whether the money you have set aside will cover your bill.


In our work with musicians and music organisations, we see how easily a routine accounting choice or missing document can create a much bigger problem. Here are four areas worth reviewing, whether you are managing your own career or looking after an orchestra’s finances.



Is cash basis accounting right for a self-employed musician?


Since the 2024/25 tax year, cash basis accounting has been the default for most eligible sole traders and partnerships. Broadly, this means recording income when you receive it and expenses when you pay them. You must opt out if you want to use traditional accruals accounting instead.


That can make record keeping simpler. But before accepting the default, musicians should consider two particular issues.


Averaging relief for composers and songwriters

Income from creative work rarely arrives in neat, equal instalments. A commission, advance or increase in royalties can make one tax year look very different from the next.


Eligible composers and songwriters may be able to use creative averaging relief to average qualifying profits over two consecutive tax years. Depending on the circumstances, this can reduce the overall income tax liability.


Averaging is not available where profits are calculated using the cash basis. Nor does every musician qualify: the nature of the creative work and the income matters.


If your income fluctuates, ask whether you qualify for averaging before deciding how your accounts should be prepared.


Tax relief on valuable musical instruments

The cash basis can also produce an unexpected result when you buy an instrument.

Some valuable instruments have a very long useful life and may retain or increase their value. Under the cash basis, expenditure on an asset that does not meet the tax definition of a depreciating asset is generally excluded from deduction. You cannot simply claim capital allowances on that instrument instead while remaining on the cash basis.


Under accruals accounting, an instrument used in the business may qualify for capital allowances, subject to the usual conditions.


There can also be a difference when you sell. Where an instrument’s cost has been deducted under the cash basis, the relevant sale proceeds generally enter the trading income calculation. That can bring an increase in value into the income tax calculation.


Before buying or selling a valuable instrument, review the tax treatment with your adviser. The accounting method affects more than the timing of your paperwork.



Why can an A1 certificate delay payment for an overseas performance?


An A1 certificate confirms which country’s social security legislation applies to your work. For a UK-insured musician undertaking eligible work in Europe, it provides evidence that UK National Insurance remains applicable.


It deals with social security. Income tax and permission to work are separate matters.

The practical difficulty is that a promoter may want the certificate before releasing your fee. Without it, they may be concerned about having to account for local social security contributions.


In our client work, delays have meant musicians waiting for payment or accepting deductions so that a fee can be released. That creates a cash flow problem even where the underlying social security position should be straightforward.


The application route also matters. A single overseas engagement and a working pattern across several countries can require different applications. The appropriate route depends on your circumstances; choosing one simply because it appears quicker can create further problems.


Once overseas dates are confirmed, check the certificate requirements, establish the correct application route and ask what evidence the promoter needs before paying you. Build the administration into your tour planning.



Has UK withholding tax been credited correctly?


For non-UK resident musicians performing in the UK, fees may be subject to withholding tax under the regime administered by HMRC’s Foreign Entertainers Unit, usually known as the FEU.


Where withholding is required, the payer deducts tax and pays it to HMRC. The performer should receive an FEU2 certificate showing the deduction.


This tax is an advance towards the performer’s UK tax liability. It is not necessarily the final amount due.


The important check is whether the tax already deducted has been properly credited when the final liability is calculated.


In one case we dealt with, HMRC amended a performer’s tax calculation and removed credit for FEU tax already withheld. The officer had confused it with separate Self Assessment payments on account. Once we explained the distinction, the original position was restored.


For the musician, however, the initial calculation showed a demand for tax that had already been paid.


Keep your FEU2 certificates alongside the relevant contracts and payment records, and make sure your adviser receives them. If a calculation looks unexpectedly high, check the credits as well as the income and expenses.



What should orchestras check before claiming Orchestra Tax Relief?


Orchestra Tax Relief is a company relief, so this section is particularly relevant to orchestra managers, production companies and finance teams.


The challenge is often applying the qualifying conditions to an actual concert programme.


Concert series elections

A production company can elect to treat a concert series as a single separate trade for relief purposes. The election is irrevocable, making the choice of concerts important.


The rules require all or a high proportion of the orchestral concerts in the series to qualify. HMRC’s guidance does not give a numerical threshold for “high proportion”.


There is also a distinction between an orchestral concert that fails a qualifying condition and an event that does not meet the definition of an orchestral concert at all. Including the latter can invalidate the series election.


The programme therefore needs to be reviewed concert by concert. Historical practice alone may not provide enough support if HMRC questions a claim.


Instrumentalists as the primary focus

The definition of an orchestral concert requires instrumentalists to be the primary focus.


Programmes involving prominent soloists, choirs or other elements can raise questions about how that condition applies. Their involvement does not, by itself, establish that a concert fails the test. The circumstances need to be assessed.


Co-productions

A shared production also needs careful planning. Only one company can be the production company for a particular concert for OTR purposes.


Co-producers should establish who meets that definition, which expenditure supports the claim and how the arrangement is reflected in their contracts and budgets.


Reviewing these points while planning the programme gives the finance team a better basis for both the claim and its cash flow forecasts.



Getting specialist tax support for a music career


A musician’s accounts need to reflect how their career actually works: the instruments they use, the income they earn and the countries in which they perform.


The same applies to a music organisation. Decisions about programmes, contracts and co-productions can affect its tax position well before a return is prepared.


If any of these issues sound familiar, get in touch to discuss your circumstances. Reviewing the position before a purchase, engagement or claim can help you avoid an expensive surprise later.

Comments


bottom of page